Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice.And, let me remind you also, that moderation in the pursuit of justice is no virtue. - Barry Goldwater
About this Entry
Posted by: SwordAndSacrifice

Visit SwordAndSacrifice's Xanga Site

Original: 7/25/2009 4:59 AM
Views: 129
Comments: 19
eProps: 24

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site

Saturday, July 25, 2009

ISLAM IS THE ENEMY

 

This is the best non-theological defense of Western civilization against Islam that I have ever heard. Ironically, the speaker, Pat Condell, is an atheist. And that's OK for the purpose of this discussion.

While I think Mr. Condell and myself will disagree about the inherent role of Christianity in developing freedom in the Western world, everything he says here beyond that is 100% spot-on.

Thanks to lonelywanderer2.

And, of course, the best theological defense of Western civilization against Islam can be found here.

 Posted 7/25/2009 4:59 AM - 129 Views - 24 eProps - 19 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

19 Comments

Visit ProvokingThought's Xanga Site!
liberal no longer means liberal, does it? Islam has always been a political religion. Good find.
Posted 7/25/2009 6:47 AM by ProvokingThought Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - reply

Visit dropsofjupiterihh's Xanga Site!

What most people don't get is that Islam does include politics.


We had our mid summer get together for our Bible study group last night.  The next study that we are doing is called The Invisible War.  We meet the 2nd. and 4th.fridays of the month, the new study is resuming on Sept. 11th.  We all found that interesting. 


I've had a someone close to me tell me "Muslims are just like Christians, they want people to convert to their religion."  I told him that Christians are not going to kill you if you don't.  That pretty much ended that conversation but that mindset (liberal)  is there.  I don't now how to change it.  I try little by little, anything more than that leads to a heated argument (not on my side, I would love to talk about it all) and is counter productive.


Great video, I hope America doesn't end up as far into it as Europe before liberals start catching on.

Posted 7/25/2009 8:41 AM by dropsofjupiterihh Xanga True Member - reply

Visit JJ_Ames's Xanga Site!
The stones cry out. He forgot to mention that Christians are amongst the groups targeted and persecuted by Islam along with women, homosexuals, and Jews.
Posted 7/25/2009 9:53 AM by JJ_Ames Xanga True Member - reply

Visit bronze_for_gold's Xanga Site!
The middle. There are many of us unwilling to call ourselves by any of the party names politically. Being in the middle seems safe. And yet we have to know that nowhere is safe from the ultimate truth and there IS an ultimate truth. That is not negotiable. It is spiritual warfare and the Holy Spirit will, in the end, win. There can be a middle politically, but not spiritually. Peace.
Posted 7/25/2009 12:14 PM by bronze_for_gold - reply

Visit Tiny_Tim_01's Xanga Site!
Islam has long been known as "The Religion of the Sword"... for good reason.
Posted 7/25/2009 12:37 PM by Tiny_Tim_01 - reply

Visit SirDoc's Xanga Site!
 I wanted to believe Islam was just another religion but there simply is no evidence for that.  I don't condone the "Crusades" but I understand them. :)
Posted 7/25/2009 2:36 PM by SirDoc - reply

Visit PreciousOnyx's Xanga Site!
Take off the PC cover and you'll find a nasty bloody history that Muslims proudly boast of. I think we need to learn to call a spade a spade and then move forward as Christians and address the heart of the issue- these are lost souls enslaved to a demonic god posing as Jehovah's middle eastern likeness. Allah always has been and always will be the moon god of the middle east and as such he is an idol to be torn down and destroyed- not treated as an equal to our Lord Jesus.
Posted 7/25/2009 2:47 PM by PreciousOnyx - reply

Visit Dead_Lands's Xanga Site!
Hate to say us, but I agree with Pogo.  "We have met the enemy and he is us."  If we hadn't decided to stop being the great nation we had once been.  If we had not turned on backs on our founding principles, Islam would be no threat to us at all.
Posted 7/26/2009 4:01 PM by Dead_Lands - reply

Visit thereluctantsinger's Xanga Site!
Great find.  Thanks for posting this one.
Posted 7/26/2009 6:27 PM by thereluctantsinger Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - reply

Visit SwordAndSacrifice's Xanga Site!

@Dead_Lands - Indeed, my friend . . . indeed.

Posted 7/26/2009 6:28 PM by SwordAndSacrifice Xanga True Member - reply

Visit istakhan's Xanga Site!
Many thanks for bringing these two commentaries to our attention.
Posted 7/26/2009 9:57 PM by istakhan - reply

Visit Direshark's Xanga Site!

@SirDoc - 

I think it is like any other religion, they just haven't had the realization that their laws are primitive and archaic. A comparison can be drawn between the Torah and the Q'oran, as Jehovah was not especially forgiving and neither were His laws. Unfortunately, I think the political structures of the Middle East ultimately prevent any sort of progress.
However, I find most Muslims living in America to see eye-to-eye on most cultural values, and so I don't believe we should include them in our collective condemning of Middle Eastern values.
Posted 7/28/2009 3:54 AM by Direshark Xanga True Member - reply

Visit SwordAndSacrifice's Xanga Site!

@Direshark - You're the person Condell is talking to.

Posted 7/28/2009 4:18 AM by SwordAndSacrifice Xanga True Member - reply

Visit Direshark's Xanga Site!

@SwordAndSacrifice - 

I'd appreciate it if you'd elaborate. I make no moves to call anyone racist or Islamophobic, and I categorically condemn the degrading and militant practices common in the Middle East.
Posted 7/28/2009 4:36 AM by Direshark Xanga True Member - reply

Visit Direshark's Xanga Site!

@SwordAndSacrifice - 

You know, because I take the charge of essentially being called treasonous, ignorant, moronic, misogynistic, and other vile adjectives as a very atrocious and unforgiving attack on my character.
Posted 7/28/2009 5:29 AM by Direshark Xanga True Member - reply

Visit SwordAndSacrifice's Xanga Site!

@Direshark - Relax, junior. And stop hallucinating. No one called you any names that you didn't heap onto your own conscience.


"I think it is like any other religion."


That statement alone shows your ignorance of Islamic history (and possibly comparative religious history). Islam is NOT like any other religion. It was a political movement that morphed into a religion. Christianity, by comparision, was a religious movement that repudiated political authority, both internal and external.


And, to further shine some light for you, Christ himself said that "not one jot nor tittle" - meaning not a period nor comma - of the Torah would pass away under Him. So the Law, or Torah, is still fully functional under Christianity. It is just no longer what Christians are judged by.


And as has been repeatedly stated for sake of comparison, most German citizens under the late-1930s Nazi regime were fine people. They simply did nothing when their nation was hijacked by hate-filled fascists. It is up to Muslims to do more than "see eye-to-eye on most cultural values." They need to start condemning the ones that their Middle Eastern counterparts advocate which are antithetical to freedom that they enjoy here in the West.


Or they can leave.

Posted 7/28/2009 6:57 AM by SwordAndSacrifice Xanga True Member - reply

Visit Direshark's Xanga Site!

@SwordAndSacrifice - 

Well, Mr. Condell certainly intoned those adjectives in his video. Perhaps I extrapolated, but only to illustrate shock at being named as the video's target. Primarily because I've heard of the people he seemed to be addressing (those who promote the burka attire) and I haven't been kind in my dealings with them.

My comparison was built strongly on the idea that a religion generally consists of a belief in a higher being, laws governing the followers of whatever deity, and rituals. SirDoc noted that he cannot view it as "just another religion." Certainly, Islam has a history that distinguishes it as unique. However, many religions have unique foundations. The origins of organized Judaism seemed to have political background - specifically, the 10 commandments and the organization of those tribes. Hinduism, the oldest mainstream religion in the world, probably had political/economic beginnings, looking at the caste system in India. It is thus that I do not think that its political background gives it uniqueness.

Returning to my original point. I'm not entirely sure what SirDoc meant by his comment, but I have most commonly heard the following argument: "The Q'oran is evil, condones murder, condones stoning, condones degradation of women, therefore, Islam is evil." I agree that these are barbaric beliefs, and those practicing them are indeed, antithetical to the freedom that we enjoy here in the West. But the God of the Torah is not kind, forgiving, or anything else. He supported the rape and genocide of a city who had a few token witchcraft practitioners, condoned stoning as a punishment for minor crimes, mandated that virgins who were raped marry their attacker, etc. It would thus be fallacious to say Islam is inherently evil while Judaism is not. And when people reference suicide bombings, I have to reference the fact that the Q'oran has clear strictures that forbid any kind of suicide.

The difference is that the vast majority of Jews have modernized and progressed, whilst Muslims follow their laws more strictly - particularly because they are often embedded in the laws of their nation. Perhaps that is what separates Islam as a religion - that it remains state-enforced, encouraging extremism. I'm of the view that should the moral authority of the Islamic church weaken in other governments, extremism AND the regressive social policies will dissipate. My end point is thus that it is just another religion, albeit one that exists in very specific social circumstances in other countries. As for Americans who have chosen to become extremists, well - they are more rare than shark attacks, and should not be used to cite Islam's ability to perverse the youth, when I'm certain that those youth really just have a disturbing desire to murder their American brothers and sisters and are hijacking a culture for that purpose.

And I agree, we can have no support or even indifference on values that could potentially threaten our freedoms, should they be brought here, and that must come from everyone, including American muslims. Theoretically, as long as Islamic countries have no quarrel with the United States, they can continue to do as they please domestically. But so long as those values incite extremism they cannot be viewed without hostility.
Posted 7/28/2009 8:53 AM by Direshark Xanga True Member - reply

Visit SwordAndSacrifice's Xanga Site!

@Direshark - ". . . but I have most commonly heard the following argument: . . . "


None of those arguments are presented here now, nor were they. Such statements were presumed.


"The origins of organized Judaism seemed to have political background - specifically, the 10 commandments and the organization of those tribes."


Judaisim's origns, specifically with Abraham being called out of Ur, are completely non-political. They are personal. The Hebrews were in Egypt prior to Moses and were identified by tribe long before Sinai. Moses had nothing to do with the tribalization of the children of Israel.


"But the God of the Torah is not kind, forgiving, or anything else."


This reveals an inherent anti-Judeo-Christian prejudice. Your references are selective - which is probably a hallmark of those unpresented arguments to which you object. For every citation you make regarding the vengance of the God of Israel, there can be found a passage showing His grace and mercy.


"I have to reference the fact that the Q'oran has clear strictures that forbid any kind of suicide."


There are, in fact, elements of Qu'ran which prohibit the slaughter of innocents. But Islam's inherent evil is not tied to those elements. Rather, as I indicated previously, it is a political philosophy that was bastardized into a theology. Taking the things of man and elevating them to a thing of God is a recipe for disaster. My understanding of Hindu theology is that its origins were also personal. This is confirmed in the Rig Veda. And while I believe that non-Godly spiritual elements were responsible for influencing the elements of the rigs, there is little argument from a literary perspective that they were personal and not political.


As an ancillary note, Judaism and Hinduism are considered to have been foundational contemporaries. It cannot be stated that either preceded the other.


All this said, there is a clear moral and philosophical superiority to Judeo-Christian theology that has placed it in an adversarial relationship with Islam since the inception of that "religion". Not Hinduism, not Buddhism, not Confucianism nor Taoism . . . none have the depth of animosity for Judeo-Christian culture that is inherent in Islam. This truth exists because one of the world's religions is not spiritual nor personal, but a man-made code forced into the frame of a god. That religion is Islam - and Islam alone.

Posted 7/28/2009 9:53 AM by SwordAndSacrifice Xanga True Member - reply

Visit Direshark's Xanga Site!

@SwordAndSacrifice - 

A fair perspective, not necessarily one that I agree with without further education on the religions themselves, but certainly with logical merit.
Posted 7/29/2009 7:59 AM by Direshark Xanga True Member - reply


Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
  • Say it with Minis! (?)

Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to SwordAndSacrifice's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in SwordAndSacrifice's local time zone:
GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)